Yes, I understand what you are saying.
So many people in the USA are having a hard time. They are looking for financial help as well.
If you want people to join your website perhaps you could start by getting a catchier name for it. You have to show people where it would benefit them to assist you. It does not matter if a person is Godly,christian or not on the website. Afterall, they do not know you from Adam & Eve. And,there is much for them to do in their own community. The Word of G-d did say that charity begins at home. So,don't get hung up on people claiming to be a christian & not helping you. Now,the Word of G-d also states its more 'blessed to give than to receive'. It tells us to give and it shall be given to us. Lets translate this into a more simple language. That would be 'if you want to receive,then you be the one to give'. Now that sheds a whole new light on the matter, doesn't it?
I am not putting your website down or anything. I am not trying to hurt your feelings. So, please do not take it that way.
If you want to get people to do something, you at least have to get their 'attention first.' Try renaming your website. Go at the angle of showing people how its to their advantage to join.
I wish you much success in your endeavors.
